Old Navy gained ground on American Eagle in Q3 2026. Same-store visits at Old Navy fell 0.5% year over year, compared with a decline of 14.3% at American Eagle. Old Navy’s share of combined visits rose from 65.3% to 69.2% (+3.9 points). Old Navy operated fewer locations (−1.3%) while American Eagle shrank by 4.2%.
−0.5% Old Navy same-store visits YoY |
−14.3% American Eagle same-store visits YoY |
69.2% Old Navy share of combined visits |
+3.9 Old Navy share change (pts) |
Which gets more visits, Old Navy or American Eagle?
In Q3 2026, Old Navy accounted for 69.2% of combined visits to the two chains and American Eagle for 30.8%. PassBy recorded visits at 1,139 Old Navy locations and 985 American Eagle locations; Old Navy’s count fell 1.3% and American Eagle’s fell 4.2% over the year.
| Q3 2026 | Old Navy | American Eagle |
|---|---|---|
| Same-store visit growth (YoY) | −0.5% | −14.3% |
| Share of combined visits | 69.2% | 30.8% |
| Locations with recorded visits | 1,139 | 985 |
| Change in locations vs Q3 2025 | −1.3% | −4.2% |
Is Old Navy gaining market share from American Eagle?
Old Navy has taken share. Old Navy’s portion of combined visits rose from 65.3% in Q3 2025 to 69.2% in Q3 2026, a shift of 3.9 points. Old Navy’s share rose in 4 of the last 8 quarter-to-quarter comparisons.
Share of combined visits across all locations with recorded visits. Because both brands are measured over the same days, share is not distorted by seasonality.
Where does each brand lead?
Across the 29 states where both chains have at least 10 locations, Old Navy drew the larger share of visits in all 29. Old Navy gained the most ground in Illinois, Ohio and Tennessee. American Eagle gained the most in California.
| State | Old Navy share | American Eagle share | Old Navy change vs last year | Leader |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| California | 74.9% | 25.1% | −1.0 pts | Old Navy |
| Texas | 66.2% | 33.8% | +2.3 pts | Old Navy |
| New York | 72.4% | 27.6% | +3.1 pts | Old Navy |
| Florida | 62.7% | 37.3% | +3.3 pts | Old Navy |
| Pennsylvania | 67.4% | 32.6% | +1.7 pts | Old Navy |
| New Jersey | 75.4% | 24.6% | +3.0 pts | Old Navy |
| North Carolina | 62.5% | 37.5% | +3.5 pts | Old Navy |
| Illinois | 73.3% | 26.7% | +6.6 pts | Old Navy |
| Georgia | 70.7% | 29.3% | +3.7 pts | Old Navy |
| Virginia | 70.8% | 29.2% | +5.3 pts | Old Navy |
Ten largest states by combined visits. Same-store locations only.
Frequently asked questions
Which gets more visits, Old Navy or American Eagle?
In Q3 2026, Old Navy drew 69.2% of combined visits to the two chains, from 1,139 locations against 985 for American Eagle.
Is Old Navy gaining market share from American Eagle?
Yes. Old Navy’s share of combined visits rose by 3.9 points between Q3 2025 and Q3 2026.
Is Old Navy foot traffic up or down in 2026?
Down. Same-store visits at Old Navy fell 0.5% in Q3 2026 compared with the same weeks of 2025.
Is American Eagle foot traffic up or down in 2026?
Down. Same-store visits at American Eagle fell 14.3% in Q3 2026 compared with the same weeks of 2025.
Which has more locations, Old Navy or American Eagle?
PassBy recorded visits at 1,139 Old Navy locations and 985 American Eagle locations in Q3 2026.
Where does Old Navy lead American Eagle?
Old Navy drew the larger share of visits in 29 of the 29 states where both chains have at least 10 locations, including California, Texas and New York.
How we measured this
Figures come from PassBy’s foot traffic panel of store-level visits. Same-store growth compares Q3 2026 (Jul 1, 2026 – Sep 30, 2026) with the same weeks a year earlier (Jul 2, 2025 – Oct 1, 2025), shifted 364 days so weekdays line up, and only counts locations with recorded visits in both periods (1,131 Old Navy and 976 American Eagle locations). Share of combined visits uses all locations with recorded visits in each quarter, so it reflects openings and closures. Brand figures cover locations operating under the named banner only (for example, not sister banners owned by the same parent company). Visit counts are panel estimates, so we report growth, share and ratios rather than raw totals. Updated quarterly.
Related comparisons
Want this comparison for your brand? PassBy tracks foot traffic, market share and trade areas for thousands of US retail and restaurant chains. Talk to our team.
